Is this time any different?
By: Shishir Nigam Tue, Feb 2, 2010
Note: See important disclaimers below article.
Another month, another year, another attempt at a correction and another inevitable bounce. The chart below highlights the sentiments carried by many investors.
All the believers of the mantra that “Nothing ever goes up in a straight line”, have been forced to challenge their beliefs when every attempt at a correction in July, August and September gave way to higher highs and higher lows. Every time the market attempted a correction the blogosphere will be awash with claims of the baseless rally finally ending.
And so here we stand again, in the middle of the most recent bounce from a seemingly major correction when the markets fell for close to 6% in the span of two weeks from Jan 20-29. Is this time any different than every other attempt? Sure, there seem to be more solid, fundamental reasons this time for a proper correction – Obama is attempting to regulate the banking sector into submission, sovereign debt problems around the world occupy the headlines, existing and new home sales came in lower than expectations. But so what? Is this time really any different? The believers of the above-mentioned mantra, the value investors, the Buffett followers, all gain hope at every market inflexion point that maybe this time the valuations will finally come closer to fundamentals. But as they wait by the sidelines for new lows to buy in, the market bounces and just keeps on going in a straight line.
The winners in the past 9 months have very much been the people who have believe that the market has little to do with fundamentals and will continue to remain disconnected from them. The winners have been those that have used different barometers from traditional fundamentalists in assessing the markets. But will that logic continue to hold weight into the future? Most likely only till the real big correction is upon us. But wait, can that even happen? Have investors already forgotten what it feels like to be in falling market?
For their sake, I hope not, because this time it might be different.
Disclosure: Long stocks, for now.
Disclaimer: Views and opinions expressed on above are those of the author alone and do not in any way represent the official views, positions or opinions of the employers – both past or present – of the author in question, or any other institutions and corporations associated with the author. Neither the information nor any opinions contained or expressed above and elsewhere on Young & Invested constitutes or should be construed as a solicitation or offer by Young & Invested to buy or sell any securities or other financial instruments or to provide any investment advice or recommendations. Young & Invested shall not be liable for any claims or losses of any nature, arising indirectly or directly from use of the information on or accessed through the site. Please see full disclaimers here.
Last 3 posts by Shishir Nigam
- The Era Of Unintended Consequences - June 13th, 2010
- First Dose Of Moral Hazard Delivered - April 18th, 2010
- Two Big Issues - RIM’s Future Hangs in the Balance - April 3rd, 2010
Tags: Corrections, economy, markets






It's certainly been a momentum investors market. I've dipped in myself a few times over the past 4 months. My picks are mostly down, although they are more value plays and so hopefully will come good long-term.
That's what more and more people are questioning now Senan, including myself. Is the market even linked to anything anymore?
It had no memory from day-to-day…one day a certain economic data point could be interpreted as a +ve for the market and the next day the same could be a -ve. There is no continuity and traditional fundamental factors have not been able to explain market moves. The only thing that has explained market movements is the US$. USD goes down, market goes up; USD goes up, market goes down. Rinse and repeat.
What a great resource!